About that Edna St. Vincent Millay poem…

November 15, 2026

“The point isn’t that the candle won’t last the night. Everything is temporary. The point is that the light is gorgeous while it lasts.”
— Exit Party: A Novel by Emily St. John Mandel
https://a.co/0b4wfH0W

Both are points. That’s the thing.

via Blogger https://ift.tt/jShVzQL

About that Edna St. Vincent Millay poem…

November 15, 2026

“The point isn’t that the candle won’t last the night. Everything is temporary. The point is that the light is gorgeous while it lasts.”
— Exit Party: A Novel by Emily St. John Mandel
https://a.co/0b4wfH0W

Both are points. That’s the thing.

via Blogger https://ift.tt/1HiTnya

Philosopher Queens Presentation

November 12, 2026

 

via Blogger https://ift.tt/xuQcZAq

Who was talking about capital letters?

November 11, 2026
“Diversity is a good; it just isn’t the only one. When competence isn’t the first criterion for appointments, everybody loses—including those women and people of color whose credentials are questioned because everyone knows those credentials were not the decisive factor in appointing them. This remains true even when Trump’s competence-free administration is so glaring that it seems to confirm the woke charge that references to competence were always an excuse to keep white men (and an occasional blond woman) in power. Yet sometimes competence really is sacrificed to representation. You’re unlikely to say it in public, but anyone reading these lines can think of examples. 15 Since January 20, 2025, the tribe being represented has changed, and disregard for quality has assumed staggering proportions. 
That group has historically held more power than any other. The claim that they should make room for others is one that many have come to accept. But when the focus on ethnic identity is elevated to first principle, champions of white supremacy will come out of the woodwork to claim it’s their turn for adequate representation. Once justice is constructed as taking power for your tribe, what’s left of politics but cold civil war? 
Prioritizing representation over competence is closely connected to preferring subjectivity to truth. This is not a generational difference. I’ve heard distinguished older scholars give powerful arguments against lies and legends, only to recoil from the word truth. Sometimes they quote Kuhn or Rorty and proclaim “I don’t believe in truth with a capital T.” Who was talking about capital letters? The question is not about metaphysical foundations but about our ability to recognize lies. After years of hearing the woke praise people for “speaking their truth,” why should we be surprised that Facebook did away with fact-checking? Inadequate as it was, at least it preserved a concept of fact. 
Only the French philosopher of science Bruno Latour was self-reflective enough to offer a public mea culpa for his own contributions to public distrust of matters of fact. At a time when Republicans use scientific uncertainties to oppose measures addressing the climate crisis or the production of vaccines, he wondered if he’d been wrong to help invent the field known as science studies, which problematized the distinction between subject and object, and emphasized the political and social dimensions of science. 
“What’s the real difference,” Latour wrote in 2004, between conspiracists and a popularized, that is a teachable version inspired by a too quick reading of, let’s say, a sociologist as eminent as Pierre Bourdieu? In both cases you have to learn to become suspicious of everything people say. . . . Of course conspiracy theories are an absurd defamation of our own arguments but, like weapons smuggled through a fuzzy border to the wrong party, these are our weapons nonetheless. 16”

— Call It Evil: Understanding the Trump Era by Susan Neiman

https://a.co/0gkffMYe

via Blogger https://ift.tt/2wQ1fOe

Whistling past it

October 30, 2026

I was sharing Halloween treats at the Honors College yesterday when the Dean approached. “I have a question: why is your Philosophy Department photo in the graveyard?” He wondered if it was meant to convey a philosophical sentiment.

Good question. I did not submit it for that use, and I don’t know who found it and posted it.

But I do recall taking the shot on a milestone birthday (they’re all milestones, at this age) while pondering Montaigne (channeling Plato and Cicero) on philosophizing as “learning to die”… As a glass-half-full person, though, I prefer the flip-side: learning to live. Same thing.

So I’m happy to stand by that photo, Dean. I’m still learning.

And then the Dean reached into my treat jar and pulled out an Almond Joy. “Sometimes you feel like a nut,” he affirmed. Yes indeed, I said. And that, too, is a philosophical observation.

via Blogger https://ift.tt/DHWsi8k

Mad, bad, and dangerous…

October 29, 2026

We’ll observe Halloween in class today, last time I’ll be doing that since this time next year I’ll be retired. 

I’ll not wear my Mad Scientist outfit to class, I’d be blind. Anyway, the Mad Anti-scientist in contemporary America is far scarier and more prevalent. Maybe I should have planned to come as RFK Jr.

via Blogger https://ift.tt/drpGaok

31 years!

October 27, 2026

October 27, 1995 was a uniquely happy day, when we welcomed to the world the kid who’d be my constant companion and unstinting delight for the rest of that decade and beyond, ’til preschool cut into our quality time at Bookstar, Davis-Kidd, the Bellevue public library, the Red Caboose Park, in the backyard playing wiffle ball, attending Nashville Sounds games and snagging Jake the Diamond Dog’s autograph…

 
What golden hours, what glorious days, what unsullied memories! 

via Blogger https://jposopher.blogspot.com/2026/10/31-years.html

William James Society newsletter, Fall 2026

October 5, 2026

 Presidential message/swan song-

This will be my last presidential dispatch to the William James Society newsletter, as I prepare to hand off the baton to John Kaag in January. It’s been a privilege and pleasure to occupy this position and this modest platform, as WJS’s 17th president. It may not be a bully pulpit exactly, or even a race, but it surely is something of a relay procession and subset of John Dewey’s “continuous human community in which we are a link.”

… (continues)

via Blogger https://ift.tt/ew0dVfv

The digital cave and the artificial state

October 2, 2026
It’s Lyceum day at MTSU with John Kaag. He’ll shed light on our digital cave. So it’s a good day, too, to start Jill Lepore’s new book…

The Rise and Fall of the Artificial State
by Jill Lepore

“The Artificial State is the factory farming of humans, the sorting and segmenting, the isolation and alienation, as if humans were becoming to machines what animals had become to humans.” 

“Much in history is headlong but few grand transformations have been more precipitate or more heedless than the rise of . . . the Artificial State,” writes Jill Lepore in this passionate account of how rule by machine has ravaged the world. Inspired by Hannah Arendt’s The Origins of Totalitarianism, which argued in 1951 that the machinery of modern life was reshaping the very fundamentals of human existence, Lepore, profoundly disturbed by the technology revolution and by the soulless inundation of artificial intelligence, unfurls a new history for our own twenty-first century. 


Building on an essay in The New Yorker in 2024, Lepore’s clarion call traces our increasing dependence on and strangulation by data. Political campaigns, awash in an avalanche of fake bots, have been reduced to attention-mining algorithms, while multinational media corporations dictate public discourse, and the era of the liberal nation-state seems to be coming to a rapid end, replaced by billionaire technocrats reliant on autocracy and the tools of AI. 


With Orwellian overtones, The Rise and Fall of the Artificial State demonstrates how technology has corroded global democracy, leading to the destruction of both human community and capacity for self-government, creating a new form of AI government, a digital citizen’s assembly, where AI will recommend the course of action to humans in place of human-run legislatures. Especially sobering with this proliferation of “dizzying, ever-changing schemes, prophesies, and predictions” is that the Artificial State has come at the expense of the natural world, leading to catastrophic loss of wildlife habitat and biodiversity. 


Deliberately alarming, The Rise and Fall of the Artificial State, despite its abundance of dire facts, is not a funeral dirge; rather, it’s an inspiring wake-up call, written in Lepore’s typically elegiac prose, which demonstrates that nothing about the Artificial State was inevitable, for it is a “government without consent, even government without humans.” It can, Lepore asserts, be dismantled. Other heinous systems, like feudalism, fascism, and slavery, have also been dismantled, but disassembly requires identifying the parts, tracing the sources. It requires telling a new history. This is the purpose of The Rise and Fall of the Artificial State.

https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/246856645-the-rise-and-fall-of-the-artificial-state

via Blogger https://ift.tt/zgbh6VH

A vote against the future?

September 30, 2026
Never mind JD or Elon on this issue…
“…When so many people hesitate to have [or adopt] children,” Sussman writes, “what is lost is not simply future taxpayers or consumers. We miss out on the rich relationships that bond us across generations, on the flood of love and tenderness that caring for children, or simply being around them, can unleash.” She adds that the “retreat from parenthood also encapsulates a dissatisfaction with our present so extreme it has become a vote against the future.”
…
https://ift.tt/aLlCq7z

via Blogger https://ift.tt/LjDCkbG