Archive for February, 2023

a gratuitous insult

February 28, 2023

Carl Sagan considers gratuitous suffering…

"First of all, you might say, "Well, evil doesn't exist in the world. We can't see the big picture, that a little pool of evil here is awash in a great sea of good that it makes possible." Or, as medieval theologians used to say, "God uses the Devil for his own purposes." This is clearly the three-monkey argument about "hear no evil…" and has been described by a leading contemporary theologian as a gratuitous insult to mankind, a symptom of insensitivity and indifference to human suffering. To be assured that all the miseries and agonies men and women experience are only illusory."

— The Varieties of Scientific Experience: A Personal View of the Search for God by Carl Sagan

https://a.co/9Ddpr6B

via Blogger https://ift.tt/mWSI5yU

Cornel West’s Friday night virtuoso performance in our building is still reverberating. He walks right to the edge of self-parody but still inspires and commands respect… even from heathens like me. I was looking around, at the end, for a collection plate! His calling out …

February 27, 2023

https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js

from Twitter https://twitter.com/OSOPHER

Einstein on Free Will and the Power of the Imagination

February 27, 2023

“Human being, vegetables or cosmic dust, we all dance to an invisible tune, intoned in the distance by a mysterious player.” 

“We are accidents of biochemistry and chance, moving through the world waging wars and writing poems, spellbound by the seductive illusion of the self, every single one of our atoms traceable to some dead star…” Maria Popova https://www.themarginalian.org/2023/02/26/einstein-free-will-imagination/  

via Blogger https://ift.tt/ulLp8Ut

Brother Cornel’s connected dots

February 27, 2023

Cornel West's Friday night virtuoso performance in our building is still reverberating. He is unrivaled in his ability to draw together and connect the dots between people and ideas most of us would never think to link. Emerson and Louis Armstrong? Sure, why not. That's avoiding evasion…

"…Thinking about my new position at Princeton, I said, "Afro-American studies was never meant to be solely for Afro-Americans. It was meant to try to redefine what it means to be human, what it means to be modern, what it means to be American, because people of African descent in this country are profoundly human, profoundly modern, profoundly American." When bell asked what the essence was of my recently published book, The American Evasion of Philosophy: A Genealogy of Pragmatism, I answered that it was "an interpretation of the emergency, the sustenance, and the decline of American civilization from the vantage point of an African American. It means that we have to have a cosmopolitan orientation, even though it is rooted in the fundamental concern with the plight and predicaments of African Americans." I went on to argue "that there are fundamental themes, like experimentation and improvisation, that can be found in the works of Ralph Waldo Emerson, for example, that are thoroughly continuous with the great art form that Afro-Americans have given the modern world, which is jazz. And therefore to talk about America is to talk about improvisation and experimentation, and therefore to talk about Emerson and Louis Armstrong in the same breath." I told the story of the cultural and political significance of the major native philosophic tradition in America best represented by Charles Sanders Peirce, William James, John Dewey, Sidney Hook, C. Wright Mills, W.E.B. Du Bois, Reinhold Niebuhr, Lionel Trilling, W. V. Quine, Richard Rorty, and Roberto Unger. My own prophetic pragmatism was the culminating point of the story…."

— Brother West: Living and Loving Out Loud, A Memoir by Cornel West

https://a.co/9UlaqFg

via Blogger https://ift.tt/nR7keS2

Bewilderment” by Richard Powers

February 26, 2023

On re-reading, I increasingly suspect Richard Powers may have read or watched and subliminally absorbed "Cosmos: Possible Worlds"-especially this week's chapter/episode ("The Man of a Trillion Worlds").

Here the brilliant "on the spectrum" little boy Robin quizzes his dad the exobiologist, as they camp under the stars in the Smokies:

"ONE MORE QUESTION, he said. What exactly do you do, again?

"Oh, Robbie. It's late."

I'm serious. When somebody at school asks me, what am I supposed to say?

It had been the cause of his suspension, a month before. The son of some banker had asked Robin what I did. Robin had answered, He looks for life in outer space. That made the son of a brand executive ask, How is Redbreast's Dad like a piece of toilet paper? He circles Uranus, looking for Klingons. Robin went nuts, apparently threatening to kill both boys. These days, that was grounds for expulsion and immediate psychiatric treatment. We got off easy.

"It's complicated."

He waved toward the woods above us. We're not going anywhere.

"I write programs that try to take everything we know about all the systems of any kind of planet—the rocks and volcanoes and oceans, all the physics and chemistry—and put them together to predict what kind of gases might be present in their atmospheres."

Why?

"Because atmospheres are parts of living processes. The mixes of gases can tell us if the planet is alive."

Like here?

"Exactly. My programs have even predicted the Earth's atmosphere at different times in history."

You can't predict the past, Dad.

"You can if you don't know it yet."

So how do you tell what kind of gases a planet has from a hundred light-years away when you can't even see it?

I exhaled, changing the atmosphere inside our tent. It had been a long day, and the thing he wanted to know would take ten years of coursework to grasp. But a child's question was the start of all things. "Okay. Remember atoms?"

Yep. Very small.

"And electrons?"

Very, very small.

"Electrons in an atom can only be in certain energy states. Like they're on the steps of a staircase. When they change stairs, they absorb or give off energy at specific frequencies. Those frequencies depend on what kind of atom they're in."

Crazy stuff. He grinned at the trees above the tent.

"You think that's crazy? Listen to this. When you look at the spectrum of light from a star, you can see little black lines, at the frequency of those stairsteps. It's called spectroscopy, and it tells you what atoms are in the star."

Little black lines. From electrons, a gazillion miles away. Who figured that out?

"We're a very clever species, we humans."

He didn't reply. I figured he'd drifted asleep again—a good end to a fine day. Even the whippoorwill agreed and called it a night. The hush in its wake filled with the bandsaw buzz of insects and the river's surge.

I must have dropped off, too, because Chester was sitting with his muzzle on my leg, whimpering as Alyssa read to us about the soul recovering radical innocence.

Dad. Dad! I figured it out.

I slipped upward from the net of sleep. "Figured out what, honey?"

In his excitement, he let the endearment slide. Why we can't hear them.

Half asleep, I had no clue.

What's the name for rock-eaters, again?

He was still trying to solve the Fermi paradox—how, given all the universe's time and space, there seemed to be no one out there. He'd held on to the question since our first night in the cabin, looking through our telescope at the Milky Way: Where was everybody?

"Lithotrophs."

He smacked his forehead. Lithotrophs! Duh. So, say there's a rocky planet full of lithotrophs, living in solid rock. You see the problem?

"Not yet."

Dad, come on! Or maybe they live in liquid methane or whatever. They're super-slow, almost frozen solid. Their days are like our centuries. What if their messages take too long for us to even know that they're messages? Like maybe it takes fifty of our years for them to send two syllables.

Our whippoorwill started up again, far away. In my head, Chester, infinitely long-suffering, was still struggling with Yeats.

"It's a great idea, Robbie."

And maybe there's a water world, where these super-smart, super-fast bird-fish are zooming around, trying to get our attention.

"But they're sending too fast for us to understand."

Exactly! We should try listening at different speeds.

"Your mother loves you, Robbie. You know that?" It was our little code, and he abided it. But it did nothing to calm his excitement.

At least tell the SETI listeners, okay?

"I will."

His next words woke me again. A minute, three seconds, half an hour later: Who knew how long?

Remember how she used to say: "How rich are you, little boy?"

"I remember."

He held up his hands to the moonlit mountain evidence. The wind-bent trees. The roar of the nearby river. The electrons tumbling down the staircase of their atoms in this singular atmosphere. His face, in the dark, struggled for accuracy. This rich. That's how rich."

— Bewilderment: A Novel by Richard Powers

https://a.co/18qUHpU

via Blogger https://ift.tt/sAgwEGd

Alan Watts, Epicurean

February 25, 2023

Alan Watts on Death, in a Beautiful Animated Short Film


What’s it gonna be like, dying? To go to sleep and never, never, never wake up.

Well, a lot of things it’s not gonna be like. It’s not going to be like being buried alive. It’s not going to be like being in the darkness forever.

I tell you what — it’s going to be as if you never had existed at all. Not only you, but everything else as well. That just there was never anything, there’s no one to regret it — and there’s no problem.

https://www.themarginalian.org/2012/10/31/alan-watts-on-death/

via Blogger https://ift.tt/Hq7sVm8

I just went on that site we former users do not name, looking for mention of last night’s terrific Cornel West event at MTSU. Found this… https://t.co/9xK4Uz3QPi

February 25, 2023

https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js

from Twitter https://twitter.com/OSOPHER

A special night in the Tennessee Room at #MTSU with the legendary Cornel West. https://t.co/loe5PW7nUI

February 25, 2023

https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js

from Twitter https://twitter.com/OSOPHER

February 25, 2023
I just went on that site we former users do not name, looking for mention of last night’s terrific Cornell West event at MTSU. Found this:

https://twitter.com/bensonbrandon10/status/1626308254526496768?s=46&t=woeWooF3dUF3dZGE1Mxj6A

I’m pleased Ed chose to tell your story, Brandon, and gratified by your success… which, as Brother West was saying last night, becomes real and meaningful when aligned with a commitment to the success and well-being of others, especially “the least of these.”

via Blogger https://ift.tt/hNCtUOF

Losing their religion

February 24, 2023

Some "divided souls" are unified and made happy ("regenerated") by religion, others by its loss. Shouldn't we welcome both kinds, and celebrate the varieties of all kinds of experience?

"Happiness! happiness! religion is only one of the ways in which men gain that gift. Easily, permanently, and successfully, it often transforms the most intolerable misery into the profoundest and most enduring happiness. But to find religion is only one out of many ways of reaching unity; and the process of remedying inner incompleteness and reducing inner discord is a general psychological process, which may take place with any sort of mental material, and need not necessarily assume the religious form. In judging of the religious types of regeneration which we are about to study, it is important to recognize that they are only one species of a genus that contains other types as well. For example, the new birth may be away from religion into incredulity…"

— VRE

https://a.co/aXpikkK

via Blogger https://ift.tt/cRqAIzC